Are you referring to the article that someone posted in this thread? Written by a Xavier student for the Xavier newspaper that is 2 years old. Techau is the only kid who is a 'transfer' who played this year. While his transfer was mainly for basketball, the others who enrolled had quotes taken out of context. Mims is not a transfer, he enrolled when he was a freshmen. Berger played for them last year came up through the school system. Joens, an all state player, came up through the school system. A few others moved in from out of town and since Xavier is a Catholic school, perhaps their faith played a role in their decision. I know we want to think it always revolves around athletics, but it is possible to pick a school based on academics or faith.
I find it fascinating that so much time and energy have been put into this discussion about a topic no one has really any control over. I attended a private school and we always heard the same argument, but what people fail to realize is the majority of the time there is more to the decision than athletics.