Juice:
I just spent about a week on a similar topic talking about Harlan's coach, and I'm going to say the same thing here that I said in that case.
First of all, don't say you're "sorry to bash on the guy." If you were sorry, you wouldn't do it.
Second, were you on the search committee? Do you know who or how many applicants for the job there were? I mean actually know for a FACT, not just what you heard at the coffee shop. Did any of the recent grads/greats who have been turned off apply, or are they just sitting off to the side complaining?
Third, where do you work? Can I go, unnamed, on a website somewhere and call you inept and a loser and wish you can get fired? If I can't why should you be able to do it to someone else?
Tell you a funny story (and this is how I know what I'm talking about). A friend of mine (Iowa native, teacher and wrestling coach) was looking to move back from out of state during the time Dave Morgan was trying to re-retire. My friend had asked me what I knew about it, and said, well, I'll make some calls. So I called the Eagle Grove AD, told him who I was, that I was an old wrestling coach and that I had heard that Morgan wanted to step down. Before I could say another word, he all but asked me if I'd be interested. I was flattered, but I explained that it wasn't for me, it was for a friend, and I wondered about possible teaching openings. He said, sadly, that no, there weren't any openings in my friend's specialty. I thanked him and wished him luck in his search.
This fact coupled with what you're saying tells me that Eagle Grove had a tough time filling the position, and maybe had to turn an individual with less experience. And in a community like Eagle Grove that has the kind of history it has, that's a tough gig. You've got about four generations of fatties sitting around at meets complaining, but who because of time or work or the personal realization that they might have been good wrestlers but have no idea whatsoever how to actually run a wrestling program, won't step up to help (in a POSITIVE manner).
Juice, unless you've actually walked in the guy's shoes, you don't know what you're talking about. And like I said, let me know where you work, so I can stop by and heckle you, too.