ADVERTISEMENT

Cumulative Top 10

I

Iabeastmode

Freshman
Gold Member
Nov 24, 2014
233
87
28
I took the 5 top rankings and combined them to come up with my top 10. Let me know what you think.
Week 3
1. Iowa City Regina (5) 50
2. Pella Christian 38
3. Dike - New Hartford 36
4. Hinton 32
West Branch 32
6. Madrid 24
7. Panorama 21.5
8. Underwood 18
9. West Lyon 7.5
10. Ridge View 3
Hudson 3
 
Last edited:
Iabeastmode said:
I took the 5 top rankings and combined them to come up with my top 10. Let me know what you think.
Week 3
1. Iowa City Regina (5) 50
2. Pella Christian 38
3. Dike - New Hartford 36
4. Hinton 32
West Branch 32
6. Madrid 24
7. Panorama 21.5
8. Underwood 18
9. West Lyon 7.5
10. Holstein 3
Hudson 3
Click to expand...
Psst....It is Ridge View...not Holstein.
 
Week 4 Cumulative Rankings
1. Iowa City Regina (4) 49
2. Hinton 40
3. Dike-New Hartford 35
3. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 31
6. Underwood (1) 23.5
7. Panora 19
8. Pella Christian 12
9. West Lyon 7.5
10. Avoca 7
 
brewcrewman1 said:
Psst....It is Ridge View...not Holstein.
Click to expand...
It'll always be Galva-Holstein to me. Ridge View...Inwould have rather had one of those alphabet soup names rather than this abomination. 'Course, if you're really old, Galva-Holstein is probably blasphemous to you but at least you can look it up on a map.
 
WBBearsFollower said:
who the heck gave Hinton a vote for #1?
Click to expand...
Hinton did not receive any #1 votes, but Underwood is #1 in BCMoore. It's a product of a unbiased early season computer ranking. I think BCMoore is a good ranking it just takes about 7 weeks to get quality results.
 
Iabeastmode said:
Hinton did not receive any #1 votes, but Underwood is #1 in BCMoore. It's a product of a unbiased early season computer ranking. I think BCMoore is a good ranking it just takes about 7 weeks to get quality results.
Click to expand...

Or Underwood for that matter. Either way Regina is #1 and its not close. For now.
 
Week 5
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Hinton 40
3. Dike- New Hartford 37
4. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 33
6. Panorama 22
7. Underwood 15 (1)
8. West Lyon 8
9. Hudson 6
10. South Winn 5
Western Christian 5
 
Iabeastmode said:
Hinton did not receive any #1 votes, but Underwood is #1 in BCMoore. It's a product of a unbiased early season computer ranking. I think BCMoore is a good ranking it just takes about 7 weeks to get quality results.
Click to expand...

Underwood...really? What quality 3A or 2A schools have they beaten this season that puts them on top of Regina and their schedule? Seems like the computer program needs some adjusting...
 
Pinehawk said:
Underwood...really? What quality 3A or 2A schools have they beaten this season that puts them on top of Regina and their schedule? Seems like the computer program needs some adjusting...[/QUOT
Click to expand...
Pinehawk said:
Underwood...really? What quality 3A or 2A schools have they beaten this season that puts them on top of Regina and their schedule? Seems like the computer program needs some adjusting...
Click to expand...
I agree, but I do think this is the most accurate top 10 out there.
 
cyard31 said:
I would put the Bears @ #2, but would bet we don't get to see #1 vs #2 again this year.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't. We are #8-10 at best right now.
That is not sandbagging, its being honest. Finnegan's injury is really a big loss to the team. His leadership and experience is what this team lacks.
 
WBBearsFollower said:
I wouldn't. We are #8-10 at best right now.
That is not sandbagging, its being honest. Finnegan's injury is really a big loss to the team. His leadership and experience is what this team lacks.
Click to expand...
I don't think there are 7-9 better teams in 1A. Luke has them in the top 25 of all classes. Dominant running back, great defense, line. Finnegan is a huge loss and I hope his recovery is going well. I don't see 8-10.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyard31
For me, it is hard to find 7 teams better than West Branch right now.

I would go...

1.) Regina - No doubt
2.) Hinton - Very athletic team. - Under the radar right now
3.) DNH - Great tradition - Great RB -
4.) West Branch - Great coaching - Great RB -
5.) Madrid - D1 talent - Weak district may hurt in the long run
6.) Western Christian - Athletic D2 team - Under the radar in maybe the best 1A district?
7.) Underwood - Great start - Very efficient passing game - Avoca game will be big (week 7)
8.) South Winn - Quality opponents -
9.) Van Meter/Panora/Avoca - All have been solid -
10.) West Lyon - Young - Western Christian and Hinton still coming up -
 
WBBearsFollower said:
I wouldn't. We are #8-10 at best right now.
That is not sandbagging, its being honest. Finnegan's injury is really a big loss to the team. His leadership and experience is what this team lacks.
Click to expand...
He is a
usfhawk said:
For me, it is hard to find 7 teams better than West Branch right now.

I would go...

1.) Regina - No doubt
2.) Hinton - Very athletic team. - Under the radar right now
3.) DNH - Great tradition - Great RB -
4.) West Branch - Great coaching - Great RB -
5.) Madrid - D1 talent - Weak district may hurt in the long run
6.) Western Christian - Athletic D2 team - Under the radar in maybe the best 1A district?
7.) Underwood - Great start - Very efficient passing game - Avoca game will be big (week 7)
8.) South Winn - Quality opponents -
9.) Van Meter/Panora/Avoca - All have been solid -
10.) West Lyon - Young - Western Christian and Hinton still coming up -
Click to expand...

loosing Finnegan does hurt but new comers are making a big impact for the Bears & are an easy #2. still to bad we won't see that matchup this year.
 
usfhawk said:
For me, it is hard to find 7 teams better than West Branch right now.

I would go...

1.) Regina - No doubt
2.) Hinton - Very athletic team. - Under the radar right now
3.) DNH - Great tradition - Great RB -
4.) West Branch - Great coaching - Great RB -
5.) Madrid - D1 talent - Weak district may hurt in the long run
6.) Western Christian - Athletic D2 team - Under the radar in maybe the best 1A district?
7.) Underwood - Great start - Very efficient passing game - Avoca game will be big (week 7)
8.) South Winn - Quality opponents -
9.) Van Meter/Panora/Avoca - All have been solid -
10.) West Lyon - Young - Western Christian and Hinton still coming up -
Click to expand...

Has anyone heard an update on the Dike-NH RB? Someone had posted that he was injured Friday night and it didn't look good. I certainly hope the kid is ok, injuries suck.
 
cyard31 said:
He is a


loosing Finnegan does hurt but new comers are making a big impact for the Bears & are an easy #2. still to bad we won't see that matchup this year.
Click to expand...

Not sure I would say an "easy" #2. They haven't blown away mediocre competition to this point. Not sure any team has claimed their position yet. One could argue that #2-10 are an even heat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyard31
usfhawk said:
Not sure I would say an "easy" #2. They haven't blown away mediocre competition to this point. Not sure any team has claimed their position yet. One could argue that #2-10 are an even heat.
Click to expand...
I would agree with that USF... but being a Bear fan I want them to get a shot @ #1 this year.
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 5
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Hinton 40
3. Dike- New Hartford 37
4. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 33
6. Panorama 22
7. Underwood 15 (1)
8. West Lyon 8
9. Hudson 6
10. South Winn 5
Western Christian 5
Click to expand...
Week 6
1. Iowa City Regina 50 (5)
2. Dike - New Hartford 39
2. Hinton 39
4. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 31
6. Underwood 23
7. Panorama 21
8. South Winn 12
9. West Lyon 8
10. Van Meter 7
Others Receiving Votes: Alburnett 3, Avoca AHSTW 3, South Cent Calhoun 3, Saints Ansgar 1
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 6
1. Iowa City Regina 50 (5)
2. Dike - New Hartford 39
2. Hinton 39
4. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 31
6. Underwood 23
7. Panorama 21
8. South Winn 12
9. West Lyon 8
10. Van Meter 7
Others Receiving Votes: Alburnett 3, Avoca AHSTW 3, South Cent Calhoun 3, Saints Ansgar 1
Click to expand...


This looks pretty close...
 
Hey USFHawk, I get to see WL in person for the first time in years in a week or so. What can I expect to see? You say they are young, at what positions?
 
pmknicks said:
Hey USFHawk, I get to see WL in person for the first time in years in a week or so. What can I expect to see? You say they are young, at what positions?
Click to expand...


West Lyon will do what they have always done. Play power football. Yes, they are young. 6-7 sophomores will start at one position or another. This week's game will be big for all of D2. Hinton is talented and well coached. Should be a good one.

What game are you coming to see?
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 6
1. Iowa City Regina 50 (5)
2. Dike - New Hartford 39
2. Hinton 39
4. West Branch 35
5. Madrid 31
6. Underwood 23
7. Panorama 21
8. South Winn 12
9. West Lyon 8
10. Van Meter 7
Others Receiving Votes: Alburnett 3, Avoca AHSTW 3, South Cent Calhoun 3, Saints Ansgar 1
Click to expand...
Week 7
1. Iowa City Regina 50 (5)
2. Dike - New Hartford 41
3. Hinton 40
4. West Branch 37
5. Underwood 32
6. South Winn 18
7. Van Meter 13
8. Alburnett 11.5
9. Saint Ansgar 10
10. South Central Calhoun 8
Others Receiving Votes: Avoca AHSTW 7.5, Madrid 5, West Lyon 1, Western Christian 1
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 7
1. Iowa City Regina 50 (5)
2. Dike - New Hartford 41
3. Hinton 40
4. West Branch 37
5. Underwood 32
6. South Winn 18
7. Van Meter 13
8. Alburnett 11.5
9. Saint Ansgar 10
10. South Central Calhoun 8
Others Receiving Votes: Avoca AHSTW 7.5, Madrid 5, West Lyon 1, Western Christian 1
Click to expand...

Week 8
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Dike - New Hartford 43
3. West Branch 40
4. Underwood 38 (1)
5. Van Meter 32
6. South Central Calhoun 22
7. Saint Ansgar 19
8. Hinton 14
9. Western Christian 12
9. Hudson 12
10. South Winneshiek 4
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 8
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Dike - New Hartford 43
3. West Branch 40
4. Underwood 38 (1)
5. Van Meter 32
6. South Central Calhoun 22
7. Saint Ansgar 19
8. Hinton 14
9. Western Christian 12
9. Hudson 12
10. South Winneshiek 4
Click to expand...

Week 9
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Dike - New Hartford 43
3. West Branch 40
4. Underwood 38 (1)
5. Van Meter 25
6. South Central Calhourn 20.5
7. Saint Ansgar 20
8. Hinton 15
9. Hudson 11.5
10. Western Christian 11
Others Receiving Votes: South Winneshiek 2
 
Iabeastmode said:
Week 9
1. Iowa City Regina 49 (4)
2. Dike - New Hartford 43
3. West Branch 40
4. Underwood 38 (1)
5. Van Meter 25
6. South Central Calhourn 20.5
7. Saint Ansgar 20
8. Hinton 15
9. Hudson 11.5
10. Western Christian 11
Others Receiving Votes: South Winneshiek 2
Click to expand...
Here's how I see it going which is a shame too most:
Quarterfinal games:
#1 vs #3
#2 vs #7
#4 vs #5
#6 vs #8 (This is the game I have a problem with)

I know I'm biased to the eastern side of the state, but ICR, DNH, & WB are by far the top 3 teams in the state and only 2 of them will be in the Semi's. With that being said the top 2 teams will not be in the finals, they will have to play in the Semi Finals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: becker30
Iabeastmode said:
Here's how I see it going which is a shame too most:
Quarterfinal games:
#1 vs #3
#2 vs #7
#4 vs #5
#6 vs #8 (This is the game I have a problem with)

I know I'm biased to the eastern side of the state, but ICR, DNH, & WB are by far the top 3 teams in the state and only 2 of them will be in the Semi's. With that being said the top 2 teams will not be in the finals, they will have to play in the Semi Finals.
Click to expand...
Beast, I agree 100% What a shame!
 
I think there are times that the West is under estimated. It may not have the overall strength of the east but they have some strong teams. Also there are times that teams in the east may be a little over rated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarkThunder#61
cidhawkeye said:
I think there are times that the West is under estimated. It may not have the overall strength of the east but they have some strong teams. Also there are times that teams in the east may be a little over rated.
Click to expand...
Be specific which teams are you referring too?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

P

Playoff Pick 'em

Replies
23
Views
4K
General Football Forum
IAROY
I
I

Week 7 Games to Watch

Replies
8
Views
2K
General Football Forum
PNation
P
I

Week 6 Games to Watch

Replies
21
Views
2K
General Football Forum
Pinehawk
Pinehawk
I

Week 5 Games to Watch

Replies
7
Views
2K
General Football Forum
ISUChip
I
P

Class 1A Season Outlook

Replies
141
Views
20K
General Football Forum
Pinehawk
Pinehawk
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT
Top Bottom
Back